Following up on my previous post, Apple just dropped a bombshell: the Safari web browser is now available for Windows. I’ve posted some general reactions at K-Squared Ramblings as to how it will benefit web developers and users overall. The most obvious is that Windows-only web designers will no longer have an excuse for not testing in Safari, which might help break the two-browser mindset.
But what about Opera, specifically?
I remember when Apple first announced Safari for the Mac, Opera was very upset that Apple had decided to go their own way instead of licensing Opera as the new default browser. In retrospect, both sides were right: Apple was right to choose something that they could maintain themselves, without being dependent on an outside provider. (I guess they’d learned their lesson from Internet Explorer.) Opera was right that they lost a golden opportunity: as the default browser on MacOS, Safari has since become the most-used browser on that platform and the third-most-used browser overall, surpassing Opera’s marketshare.
So there’s certainly a risk that Safari on Windows could surpass Opera’s users. However, there is one significant difference: Safari is not the default browser on Windows. It’s hard to tell how much of Safari’s uptake on MacOS is due to it being the default, and how much is due to people actively liking it. Personally, I have Opera, Firefox, and a half-dozen other browsers on my PowerBook, but when I fire that box up, I generally use Safari.
If you look at the functionality available in a base install, from simplest to most complex, it probably starts with Safari, runs through Firefox and IE, then finishes with Opera. Firefox has a wide array of extensions available — in fact, it’s pretty much known for them. Safari isn’t nearly as extensible.
You can’t install something that will add mouse gestures, for instance.
I suspect that, at least at first, the audience for Safari on Windows will consist mainly of the following groups:
- Web Developers
- Dual-platform users who are used to Safari on Mac
- People who just want a basic browser and don’t want bells and whistles, but don’t want IE for some reason
If anything, I think Firefox has more to worry about than Opera. For every Firefox user who tricks out his browser with every 1337 extension he can find, there are probably many who just wanted something more stable than IE, or faster than IE. There’s a vocal faction of Firefox users who are frustrated with its performance. I don’t know why they haven’t jumped ship to Opera, but depending on how much memory Safari uses when it gets out of beta, it might prove a threat on that front.
- K-Squared Ramblings: Safari on Windows
- Alternative Browser Alliance: Why Alternative Browsers?
- Opera Watch: Safari coming to Windows
- Opera Forums: Safari for Windows
*This post originally appeared on Confessions of a Web Developer, my blog at the My Opera community.
What windows people are still missing is the pure KHTML engine to test against. That should change not so far into the future, when KDE4 goes stable (ported to win).
More developers will test site in safari. Opera might face interesting challenge!
Nitpick: "Safari isn't extensible. You can't install something that will add mouse gestures, for instance."
Check it: http://pimpmysafari.com/plugins/cocoa-gestures-12
Interesting! I was not aware of that. Fixed!
@koayf But do these work for Safari windows though?
An annoyance is, at least on my MacBook Pro, that Safari 3 beta is much quicker than the fastest browser on earth……
Safari tends to display text and images immediately when loading, while Opera waits for seconds before loading anything. Didn't use to be like that!
@shoust: Dunno. I don't really like mouse gestures and I didn't want to install any extra junk on my browsers (Firefox has enough bloat as-is.) If you really want me to test, I can.
@jakob: That's odd. In my experience, it's Safari that waits for the entire page to load before it starts displaying it.
I have d/l Safari, just to see what it is. I generally use Opera and only for some websites I have to go back to IE (some drop down menus not working in Opera). I love the mouse gestures in Opera. I find myself trying to use them in IE or Windows Explorer and then realising they're not working there 🙂
I used to have Firefox with mouse gestures plugin installed, but it just hasn't the same sensitivity or something. Unfortunately, the CocoaGestures being advertised here as a solution for mousegestures in Safari isn't free anymore. You have to install something called CocoaSuite and after 30-days you have to pay for it. Too bad…
So I'll stick to Opera!!
@shoust, doc, etc.
I tried the mouse gestures one, and, as Doc already mentioned it costs money. No way am I paying for browser functionality. That is outrageous, especially considering the thousands of Firefox extensions and Opera widgets I have at my disposal.
Plus, it's my understanding, in my very limited concept of programming languages that these AppleScripts rely on Cocoa which cannot function on Windows. I do not know, but this is what I hear. If I'm wrong, I would like to know otherwise.
Why did you cross off Mouse Gestures in your post? The Coca Suite (which is not free) requires OSX and thus will not work on Windows!
Since the way that the sentence is worded is vague, it's hard to say if it should stay or go. Safari at large can in fact have mouse gestures, but Safari on Windows (apparently) cannot.